Have
you tried any listening or speaking techniques with your conversation
partner or class this semester? If so, discuss how successful they
were, and what you could have done to improve upon them. If no, think
about what you could do with your class/partner,
and try it out this week. Ideally, report back on how it went.
(Additional comments on this post no longer earn points. Please choose a more recent entry).
(Additional comments on this post no longer earn points. Please choose a more recent entry).
I am always trying to elicit verbal responses from my class. They do a lot of listening and speaking activities, and not as much reading and writing. That being said, we do a lot of pair work where they have to talk to each other and write down the responses and then report back to the rest of the class. I have 27 students in my class so having everyone talk individually for any length of time is usually not possible. One technique that I use in class is to choose a topic and then have partners talk to each other about their opinions on that topic, write a short paragraph about it and then report back to the rest of the class. I think that this very successful on several fronts. First, it gets people talking to each other without being afraid of making a mistake in front of the entire class. They have time to communicate and refine their answers before they have to actually produce in front of everyone else. Second, they have to take what they hear (listening) and turn it into written form so there is a comprehension component to it as well. Finally, it is meaningful and communicative as the class members are actually interested in what each other has to say and I have had some spontaneous lessons turn up just based on what each of the students has to say about a particular issue (gives the opportunity to talk about related grammar or cultural points).
ReplyDeleteWith my conversation partner, I suppose I practice speaking with her by starting a topic I imagine a girl her age would be interest in. Usually, she jumps right in and begins talking and then at that point, if she makes a mistake in pronunciation, I will repeat the word she said correctly without saying, "oh, that's actually pronounced..." Just repeating it allows her to correct her mistake. Giving her free reign to talk about what she is passionate about, when she is at a loss for a word she wants to use, I can help her by offering suggestions and she has been learning new vocabulary that way.
ReplyDeleteI think the key when dealing with conversation partners (I'm not sure about a classroom setting as I don't teach a class), is letting them talk about what they want. It's ok to have some topics to present but if the student isn't interested, it will only be a lesson in listening and the student may zone out and really not receive much benefit at all.
With my conversation partner we practice speaking a lot, especially when she has to present something in her class, she always practices with me first. It’s different from normal conversation when you’re doing a presentation, and so I would tell her a couple of pointers on what to do (or not to do). For example, she would jump from topic to topic and then come back to one or the other, and she could not present everything in a “flow.” So, we made an outline, with each of the main topics, and then I told her to write a sentence about what she is going to say for each one. After practicing with the outline in front of her for the first couple of times, she then got better, and so now she can to some extent keep her ideas connected. Another thing was that she was sort of hesitant to look or face who she is talking to, and so I talked to her about that too, and I told her that how usually presenters stand, how they make contact, face the audience, etc, and gave her a little example. In normal conversation though, she speaks very well, except that sometimes she has trouble with forming questions, and so she will say something about what she is trying to ask, and then I would ask the question for her (keeping the conversation in normal flow, so that it doesn’t seem like a blunt correction), and she goes on from there. I think my partner has become really good at speaking! When I talk with her it’s almost as if I’m talking with one of my “native” friends.
ReplyDeleteLast semester, my conversation partner and I used tongue-twisters to help her with her pronunciation. And idioms were also a good source of discussion. The tongue-twisters were used to help her with the sounds l and r. Once she learned where her tongue needed to be to produce the r we then worked on tongue-twisters as well and random conversations about dating and other things she was interested in knowing. Once she got comfortable with me and realized that I wasn't here to test her or judge her she would speak freely and with enough practice she got better at pronouncing the r-sound. I would only point it out when she got it right and since I was excited for her she would get excited and puff her chest out in pride! The tongue twisters were just a method to help practice the sounds but the everyday conversations and not correcting her very time she opened her mouth helped too!
ReplyDeleteIdioms were just another type of discussion topic. Neither one of us had known there were so many. So she would pick a few she was interested in knowing and using and we would discuss meaning and she would practice using them with me during text messaging and discussions. My conversation partner was a hard working student and her first words to me were, "I am not good with speaking Engrish, please correct me when I say it wrong!" My response was, "no problem" but I didn't correct her every time she opened her mouth instead I just let her talk and when I noticed where she had issues we would practice. She was very receptive to all my suggestions and worked very hard.
Stefani Goode
This semester I have tried several speaking and listening techniques to help my students improve.
ReplyDeleteOne method I tried was getting them to read aloud various Dr. Seus books. They all thought this was silly at first, but the words are all so similar that it's hard to say when not paying close attention. After a while, they seemed to enjoy it and found it rather challenging. I made them read it over and over so they could start building their speed when reading aloud.
I also tried several conversation techniques. These were less successful and could probably use some improvement. The first time I tried this, I put my students into pairs (so they were forced to talk) and gave them a topic. The topic required the student to talk about themselves. Each student took turns telling their partner about themselves and then they were to present their partner to the class. Well, my students were either reluctant to talk or they got off topic. When it was time to present, only one pair did it successfully. The rest of the pairs wanted to present themselves, not their partner. When I prompted them to discuss their partner NOT themselves, they then had to re-ask everything because they had already forgotten. It was a disaster. I think if I try this technique again, I'll refine it a lot. For example, I'll have the students write down key information so that if they do forget they'll have something to go off of. Also, I need to do a better job of keeping them on topic. I was more worried about the students who weren't talking that I didn't notice when the students who WERE talking weren't on task. Another thing I noticed was that some students were very excited to talk about themselves, and others were reluctant. I think next time I'll try and find a topic that everyone is comfortable with.
Last class, I taught students “Taboo” to help them practice their vocabulary. Students drew a card with a vocab word on it and then had to get their group to guess the word without saying the word itself. This activity forced them to find strategies for describing a word. After the first round, I had to make some emendations to the rules such as “no using your hands” and “only do one word and then pass the deck of cards to the next person” because faster students would go through all the words themselves and not let slower students have a chance to describe any words! Under these modified rules, the activity went more smoothly as students had to use their oral skills and everyone got a chance to play. As the activity progressed, I listened to students’ strategies for describing words. After the activity, I wrote a few on the board such as giving the time and place: “This is happens in the living room when I don’t want to do anything (watch TV)” or giving an example “making pie and bread (baking)”. I think this activity was fairly successful in that it helped students review vocabulary in a creative way, gave them practice in their oral description and listening comprehension skills, and was fun. To improve this game, I could start out with my modified rules and connect this game to a communicative purpose and context.
ReplyDeleteOne of my conversation partners this semester is very insistent on bringing phrases he hears that are difficult to understand to me to help with. The last one was "about it" he says, "The teachers spell it like this but it sounds like aboudit, say it!" He loves to get me to say things and then he repeats what he hears me say. Since he is already interested in, and understand this phonological property of English, I should look for other words and phrases with phonological manifestations that are different from the spelling.
ReplyDeleteI experienced real challenges in using listening activities with my students this semester. We were working in a small room that contained not only our group but two other groups with their own teachers, and so the ambient noise level became really crazy sometimes and the students simply couldn't hear me well enough for me to accurately test their listening skills. That being said, I did use story comprehension and/or short dictation exercises in class that forced them to listen carefully. One of the most successful listening activities we did had to do with minimal pairs, and the students really were enthusiastic in their response to the challenge. We also had a great time during a week when I demonstrated and had them mirror some phrases like the one Hayley mentioned above "about it" that we ordinarily smash together in pronunciation. I didn't spend a lot of time on that but it got a huge response from the students because it was clearly something they've encountered in trying to have English conversations with people.
ReplyDeleteThe textbook my community program was using this year was very drill-heavy when it came to speaking activities, so I tried to move away from it as much as possible and make nearly all of the activities communicative instead. This wasn't always possible but it definitely helped. I also enjoyed the fact that teaching in this particular program I had the leeway to simply engage the students in guided conversation on normal everyday topics at times and just leave the textbook behind. Some of the most successful speaking that was done in class was during these directed conversations, since students would still look to me to supply correction or help as they discussed their weekend or some issue of daily life.
There is lots of listening and speaking between my conversation partner and I. I usually bring up topics and discuss them for a bit asking his opinion about what ever topic we might be discussing. My partner likes to be challenged and I don’t hold back in the conversation. His main focus is to be fluent and I use every day English language mixing in slang words. Slag was one of our topics this past weekend and we spent a good deal of time discussing it. We focused on conversation he might have heard outside of class that he found challenging to understand.
ReplyDeleteWe also talked about trying to pull out chunks of conversation when he speaks with native speakers outside of class. We go over words and meaning he might be having difficulty understanding. We headed over to a T-mobile store and he got some practice in going over calling plans with an employee there. I don’t even understand some of those calling plans.
I have done a few different things to varying degrees of success. First I tried just having a list of handy topics in case we didn’t have anything to talk about, but I’ve found that I’ve never actually used it! I started out just asking her questions about herself, but she got hung up on vocabulary that she didn’t know and just used her phone to look up the word. I finally asked her to tell me about the word and we’d come up with the right word together. It worked! We’ve made a game of this, and a lot of times she brings me a list of words she’s heard, (spelling is iffy), and I ask her to tell me what she thinks they mean. I use them in sentences and this makes her listen for context, meaning, and pronunciation. I plan on modifying this for classroom use. We talk about idioms she hears on TV and in class such as the famous, “See what I mean?” and mainly we talk about the differences between our two cultures and L1s. She’s finally gotten comfortable enough with me to ask me questions and that broken barrier has been the biggest help to her.
ReplyDeleteMy conversation partner really wanted to watch a movie together and chose Harry Potter. I didn't realize that she was going to pause the movie every time she didn't understand something and use me as her human dictionary! We made it about 5 minutes into the movie (after about 20 minutes), at which point I convinced her switch to something a little more reality-based without made-up words! As far as speaking/listening goes, this method of learning seems a bit disastrous to me. She stopped the movie so many times that the flow and gist of the movie were lost. It's important to teach students to listen globally without getting hung up on the details. Stopping the movie for every word or phrase you don't know suggests that each word is of equal importance, which is not true. I tried to explain to her that I couldn't imagine any context in which she would need to say or even hear "Word to your momma," but she insisted on recording it anyway. I think movies can be useful tools, but next time I would 1) maintain control over the remote myself and 2) stop periodically, perhaps at the ends of scenes and infrequently after phrases she definitely needs to know. Then I could ask global questions about understanding and define any language crucial for understanding - but not before having her guess at the meaning based on the context.
ReplyDeleteMy conversation partner has been studying for the EILTS and a good portion of our time together has been her practicing speaking on a topic for two minutes to prepare for the test. I rarely interrupt her, but occasionally she will stop to ask "Is it right?" or "Can I say that?" or ask for clarification for vocabulary or pronunciation. She asked me to try a few of the prompts and she took notes on how I worded phrases and then asked me about them afterwards ("when can I use...?" "How did you say...?) Although a lot of what we have been working on is very specific to her test, I think we have still managed to work on listening and speaking.
ReplyDeleteKailey Watson
Jarrod Duarte
ReplyDeleteI tend to focus more on listening skills in my class, and let speaking come naturally. I focus on listening skills by doing some pre-reading activities and asking comprehension questions of a story that I read out loud, also I rarely correct them when they respond orally unless it is an egregious mistake or a consistent one. I do this because I am trying to lower their affective filter when it comes to speaking. Additionally, I tend to stay away from the students reading out loud for practice because I believe some of the students aren't very literate in their L1 even.
Jarrod Duarte
While there are some listening and speaking elements built into the textbook my program uses, I have only done one, that I can think of, that I created on purpose. My students were having a hard time distinguishing “s,” “sh,” and “ch” in order to pronounce them. Often I do not correct pronunciation in my class, but in this case it was affecting their ability to clearly communicate their point. So I explained the differences between these three, and also “sch” since it looks similar orthographically, writing examples on the board. I then wrote these four in separate corners on the board and said words that had these sounds. In particular I tried to pick sounds that had a minimal pair with one of the other sounds like “shell” and “sell.” The students would point to which one I was saying. This seemed to help them, but I would have liked to make it more interactive because really this was just a drill of sorts. Perhaps after doing a few myself I could have turned it into an activity where the students come up with some examples and then take turns saying their words and trying to stump their peers. Of course I would have to only count it if they pronounced it correctly and it was their peers who were not able to hear it.
ReplyDelete